by
Greek Giant

We’ve seen this movie before: Giants take a lead late, closer blows it. Yesterday, in their 7-6 loss to the Twins, which gave the Giants a bitter sweep in Minneapolis at the hands of the Twins who have won eight consecutive games, Ryan Walker again failed to get the save/win and coughed up another lead.

Here’s what happens often when someone rises to power: They suffer from “smartest person in the room” syndrome. It’s real and I can give you a million examples: Farhan Zaidi, Elon Musk, etc. What is SPITR syndrome, you ask? Allow me to explain: SPITR syndrome occurs when someone believes they are possessors of a personal brand of genius, intelligence or insight, despite all evidence to the contrary and that is unique to them and them only. Suffers of SPITR show signs of arrogance, or refusal to acknowledge empirical evidence, of operating in a void and are often guilty of being oblivious to the usually disastrous consequences of their decisions. They never take responsibility for their failed moves because, at heart, they fragile little narcissists.

SPITR sufferers are usually high-achievers who, despite their rise to powerful positions, have become tainted with a god-complex attitude when it comes to their opinions of themselves. No matter the continuous terrible outcomes, sufferers of SPITR syndrome refuse to acknowledge defeat or their mistakes. The syndrome includes a level of obsessive stubbornness combined with narcissism and arrogance and a detachment from the world beyond their inner circle.

Giants Manager Bob Melvin is now officially afflicted with SPITR syndrome. His insistence on inserting Ryan Walker into the closer role is costing the Giants game after game and is the equivalent of Managerial Malpractice. For those of you who read this blog and have followed my writings over the years, one thing is clear: I generally do not criticize players or Managers or front office personnel. It is a rare occurrence in my posts as I prefer to take a magnanimous attitude and focus on positives. But sometimes, situations call for a sincere critical analysis. Let’s face it, mainstream journalism is dying in part because you do not get the unvarnished truth from most writers, particularly in the sports world. When it comes to the Giants this season, it is clear to anyone with eyes, that Ryan Walker is struggling. His slump is so disastrous it has lead directly to 3-4 Giants losses (I’ve lost count), in games he has appeared with the Giants leading. Yet Bob Melvin continues to trot him out to the ninth or extra innings to be the Giants closer, even when his makeup and his stuff are not suited to closing Major League Baseball games. Last year Walker had a superb season. This year, with yesterday being the latest example, he has been a near total disaster. One note: Technically Bob Melvin was not in the game since he was tossed earlier for arguing a called- check swing out but his use of Doval earlier in the game and the appearance of Ryan Walker in the tenth were his design and his decisions for yesterday’s loss.

In yesterday’s 7-6 loss, one of the worst of this young season, the Giants were leading Walker coughed up a one-run lead and the game. In the process the Giants have the best bullpen in the Majors and have many other options for the closer role, including Tyler Rogers, Randy Rodriguez and Camilo Doval, each of whom are having super duper seasons. That Melvin insists on using Walker as the closer is a sign of SPITR syndrome and a misguided attempt at showing loyalty to Walker and “standing behind his players.” If I am a starting pitcher on the Giants staff I threaten a strike unless Melvin puts Walker where he belongs, in the eighth or seventh inning role. We’ve come to a point where Melvin’s sanity and intelligence must be questioned.

This is not to say Ryan Walker is not a good pitcher or he has no value to the Giants. On the contrary, while he appears to be absolutely healthy, his slump could be due, in part, to him throwing 80 innings last season in 76 games. That’s way beyond his previous amounts in his career. It is likely that workload has taken a toll on him this year. Walker was never the classic power pitcher one expects in the closer’s role, a role that prefers strike outs to contact and power to finesse.

It will be interesting to see how far the madness continues. Well, maybe interesting is not the word but it is high time Bob Melvin finds the way to simply use Walker in another role, one at which he excelled in previously, which is to say, as a set-up man. There is no shame in admitting mistakes. In fact, it’s a sign of maturity and wisdom, two qualities essential for successful humans and successful Baseball Managers.