The Giants were eliminated from postseason contention on Saturday. It’s not the end of the world. We all saw it coming and I must say, good on the Giants for playing well to end the season. Their hot run in which they went 18-10 for September, their best month since April, meant that they were not eliminated from the new super, duper expanded MLB postseason picture until five games were left in the year. We can look at this three ways:
- Where was this play in July and August when the Wild Card was there for the taking?
- The Giants exhaled after being effectively eliminated and played without pressure, thus uncorking their young toys like Villar, Vosler and others.
- Evan Longoria got well too late in the season.
I would love to tell you I will do a scintillating analysis of all three reasons but the truth is that’s Dr. Lefty’s or GG”s forte. I’m just here to blow steam after a weekend in which the Giants were eliminated but still took two of three from the Diamondbacks in the final home series of the year. This weekend also saw the Willie Mac Award go to Wilmer Flores, Everybody’s favorite to win the award.
Sooooo, all in all it was a nice weekend, punctuated by an exciting walk-off win yesterday that saw David Villar grab a victory from the fangs of defeat against the DBacks.
The Giants used eight pitchers in yesterday’s 4-3 ten inning win at Willie Mays Field. Gabe Kapler decided to empty the bullpen to let the fans get one last look at the likes of Alexander, Szapucki, Young, Rogers, Miller, Brebbia (I’m still not finished with this list), Doval (still not finished), and Cotton. Cotton was the last man standing so he got the win, despite giving up the go-ahead run in the top of the tenth inning.
The scoring started when Evan Longoria lined a sac fly to left with the bases loaded and one out. That scored Flores. The ball hit by Evan was a laserbeam on a curveball about knee-high. In other words, the veteran hit a decent pitch to get the Giants on the board first. Longoria is BACK! Buuut, don’t be fooled, If’ I am the Giants I let him walk next season. His body can no longer withstand a 162-game season and I want to see the Giants get younger, faster, meaner and more athletic.
If Johnny Black is the GM it would be “So Long Longo, nice to know you. You were a good Giant with a snakebit career in San Francsico.”
But back to the game: In the top of the fifth the Dbacks tied it at one run apiece on a double by McCarthy. He scored from first on a close play.
The Giants took the lead on a home run to left field by Austin Slater. It was a rare homer in which Slater pulled the ball and you could see him thinking as he swung on an inside fastball “Oh, that’s what pulling for power feels like!”.
— SFGiants (@SFGiants) October 2, 2022
The long ball made it 2-1 Giants. After Arizona tied it at 2 each in the top of the eighth inning we went into extra innings and Villar’s heroics. The winning rally started with a walk to Wilmer and J. D. Davis’s infield single to load the bases. Walks will kill you in extra innings!
Here is the Villar game-winner. Get used to more of these in the future. The kid has a knack:
First career walkoff hit for the kid 👏 pic.twitter.com/D6jznGMYP2
— SFGiants (@SFGiants) October 2, 2022
The Giants lost 8-4 on Saturday. That loss along with the Phillies win meant curtains on the Giants postseason dreams for 2022.
Yaz hit his 17th homer and Davis hit his 12th. Junis took the loss allowing eight hits and four runs in four and two third innings of work. Jameson, the Arizona starter, was much better allowing two runs in six innings and getting the win. The difference in this game was the starting pitching. Once again the Giants went with a bullpen approach for the starting pitcher, started here by Scott Alexander.
The Black Monday Weekend Wrap©
I do not want to wax too poetic about this weekend’s games. The Giants ended the home season with a respectable record of 44-37 at Willie Mays Field. So far this season they are 36-42 on the road with the final series in San Diego to play this week. That difference helps explain the absence from the postseason, quite frankly. If I were to list the reasons why the Giants did not make it to playoff baseball, in order of priority I would go thusly:
- Terrible, historically awful defense (infield, outfield, catcher, everywhere a baseball is hit or thrown) Those extra runs, extra pitches thrown, meant at least 10 losses by my unofficial count. Even with an average defense the Giants probably win the final Wild Card.
- Horrible Middle Relief. The Giants had far too many close games where the starter was gone after five or so innings and the middle relief corps was lit up for a bunch or just enough tack-on runs to make the game out of reach and turn a potential win into an “L.”
- Underperforming Starting pitching from the four and five spots in the rotation. This lead to too much bullpen usage. It also lead to too many games where we did not know who was going to pitch. It affected the defense. It affected the general psychology of the line up and it lead to a big amount of losses. I would venture to say that if we did a stat count of the Giants record in games pitched by the fourth and fifth starter they would be waaaaay under .500.
- Lack of offense from the outfield. Lookat Yaz’s .217 average. Wade was invisible most of the season, either due to injury or simply not hitting. Slater was used too sparingly and was hurt a bit. Joc is a DH. You see where I am going with this? The Giants need to rebuild their outfield from top to bottom. Sorry, but Yaz is at best a fourth outfielder. I would argue Slater may be competent everyday in left. But who is going to play right?
- Down year from Craw. Just a terrible offensive season from the Giant shortstop.
- Age, age, age. Belt and Crawford missed too many games and the Giants did not get enough offense or defense to make up for their absences. It’s time to move on from both.
Here is Larry Baer’s annual end of season letter to Giants fans:
— SFGiants (@SFGiants) October 3, 2022
I’m looking forward to April 2 in Scottsdale too, Larry.