by DrLefty

SCOTTSDALE, Ariz.–We had a great time at yesterday’s game, and I have lots of pictures to share with you. The park was packed, the weather was perfect, and the Giants won. More on the game in a minute.

 

We had tickets in Section 300. These are not the fanciest seats, but we think they’re the best in the house because they’re in the shade, and as you can see, we were right behind home plate. Over my left shoulder, I could see Alex Pavlovic and Andrew Baggarly in the press box. I didn’t get there quite early enough to go say hi, but I’ll try to do so today. It took me a couple of innings to look right behind me, and just three rows back, in their own box, were members of the Giants’ brain trust. You recognize the ones on the end, I’m sure, and it was Javi Lopez between them. At points during the game, Zack Minasian was in there, too. I’m not sure if they were just concentrating intensely or scowling because they saw I was taking a picture, but too bad for them. I’m a reporter and I’m on the clock!

 

 

 

 

 

I also got a nice photo of Ron Washington saying hi to Reds manager Terry Francona and of Tony Vitello at home plate with the lineup card. Oh, and Lou Seal, of course.

Oh, yeah, the game

The Giants won 6-3 for their sixth straight Cactus League win and lead the league at 10-2, also with the best run differential at +36. Only the Yankees in the Grapefruit League have a better run differential (+39). They continue to win with a lot of scoring (7.4 runs per game!) and are second in MLB with a .898 OPS and a team batting average of .318 (!!!), which leads the majors. Bear in mind that their starting outfield is all off with their respective WBC teams, as is their starting 2B, and that Rafael Devers is nursing a minor injury and hasn’t played all week. The team pitching has improved; their ERA of 4.26 is now tenth in the majors. As I noted last week, a big part of their ugly team pitching stats could be attributed to two terrible appearances by Hayden Birdsong, and they prudently kept him on the back field in a simulated game this week. Anyway, except for that game against Team USA that doesn’t count, the Giants are doing great here in the desert.

There were some notable performances yesterday. Non-roster invitee Jared Oliva got things started by getting hit by a pitch, stealing second, stealing third, and then scoring on a sacrifice fly hit by Willy Adames. Oliva was 57 for 63 in stolen base attempts for AAA Nashville last year, so this is no fluke. Then in the second inning, Bryce Eldridge and Luis Matos went back to back with scorched balls to the center field batter’s eye; Eldridge’s was a triple and Matos’s was a double, scoring Eldridge. Both balls would have been homers in any major league park, and it was nice to see Eldridge rip one against a lefty pitcher. Matt Chapman hit a two-run homer in the third, and Matos hit a homer in the sixth.  Here’s Eldridge’s triple.

 

On the pitching side, Tyler Mahle started and went two scoreless innings for the win. The stuff and velocity looked good, but he did walk three in two innings. Trevor McDonald, who absolutely seems in the mix for a bullpen role, pitched three scoreless innings, giving up two hits and a walk and striking out two, again with good velocity. The save went to lefty NRI Juan Sanchez. The only messy innings were by NRIs Caleb Kilian (who got dinked and doinked a bit) and Wilson Ramos (don’t worry about remembering his name; I don’t think he’s really in the mix). Overall, though, the game seemed under control from the beginning. It’s nice to see the Giants scoring early and often.

 

Roster Battles

With our My26ManGuysâ„¢ ballot deadline coming up in a few days (see below for information on how to enter), it’s a good time to revisit where things (might) stand. Some injuries and some (under)performances may be making things a bit clearer, but as I’ve learned in previous rounds of this contest, you just never know. (For example, in 2024, Erik Miller was one of the earliest cuts, so I put Juan Sanchez on my ballot as the second lefty, and then Miller made the Opening Day roster. No complaints, but it was an odd chain of events.)  Anyway, here’s how things appear right now.

 

Bench Roles

Daniel Susac appears to be holding his own in camp, and he’s still the front runner for the backup catcher job because of his Rule 5 status (unless, as Surf Maui pointed out last week, the Giants make a deal with the A’s to keep him if they want to option him. I could see that if they like NRI Eric Haase’s veteran presence enough to want to keep him around.).

If we assume that Casey Schmitt has the inside track as the all-purpose backup infielder and Christian Koss as the utility guy (because he can play outfield and even “pitch,” which Schmitt, a very good college closer, probably could also do), that leaves one open bench spot for another backup outfielder. Here’s what it gets interesting. So far, it’s a completely right-handed-hitting bench. So you’d think a lefty-hitting outfielder would get that final spot, and both Matos and Jerar Encarnacion could be DFA’d, since they’re out of options. Under that scenario, with Drew Gilbert nursing a shoulder injury, it would seem to be a battle between Grant McCray and NRI Will Brennan. Both are having good springs at the plate and have similar skill sets. McCray is on the 40-man roster and Brennan is not; on the other hand, Brennan also has a career .297 batting average in 158 major league plate appearances, and McCray, who is three years younger, has…not that. Both Brennan and McCray have minor league options, so keep that in mind.

This “bench roles math” may change depending on the next item, which is, of course…

 

Big Bryce

Eldridge, who got to meet his boyhood idol/namesake Bryce Harper during the Team USA exhibition game and also compare heights with Aaron Judge, is not making things easy on the decision makers, and good for him. He’s hitting the ball really hard and really far. He killed a ball off Paul Skenes in the exhibition, and only a great running catch by Gold Glove CF Byron Buxton kept it from being a probable triple. His current slash line is .273/.385/.636/1.021, and yes, he’s struck out 8 times in 25 plate appearances, and yes, that’s too many, but have I mentioned that five of his six Cactus League hits have been for extra bases, and he hit them really hard and really far?

Here’s the other thing. We had a great view of him playing first base yesterday, and he looks very credible there. I wouldn’t say his hands are as steady and reliable as Brandon Belt’s were, but…it looks like he could get there.

On the Splash Hit Territory podcast this week, Susan Slusser commented that scouts around the league are “weirdly divided” about whether Eldridge should make the team or begin the year in AAA. All of them think he’s a special talent, but some of them argue that he’s too special to rush at age 21, while others say he’s ready and why not let him try it? Slusser commented that Bryce is a mature and confident young man and that if he starts out with the Giants, has a rough month, and gets sent down, it won’t faze him at all.

After seeing him this week on TV and in Scottsdale Stadium, I’m inclined to think he’s going to force the issue and be on the Opening Day roster, and that would be very exciting!  John Shea of the SF Standard also thinks Eldridge should say and even put out possible alternate lineups for the Giants depending on the starting pitcher.

Against a RHP:                                                                    Against a LHP:

Arraez                                                                                     Ramos

Devers                                                                                    Devers

Adames                                                                                  Adames

Ramos                                                                                   Chapman

Eldridge                                                                                 Arraez

Chapman                                                                              RH DH (maybe Schmitt)

Lee                                                                                        Lee

Bader                                                                                   Bader

Bailey                                                                                   Bailey

I’m not sure about Shea’s suggestion to use Schmitt as a DH; if he’s starting, I think he should play 2B and Arraez can DH that day, but otherwise, I like it. I’d been thinking Ramos should hit higher than Chapman, who’s really a #6 hitter at best, but putting Eldridge fifth was more aggressive than I was thinking–I’d probably drop him to seventh so that he’s not under too much pressure.

 

The Bullpen

I’ll make this quick because this column is getting long and I need to move on with my day (get ready to go to the game!), but…this is a mess, and it’s an even bigger mess when you consider that Reiver Sanmartin, Joel Peguero, Sam Hentges, and maybe even Miller are questionable for Opening Day because of injuries. So we can probably pencil in Ryan Walker, Jose Butto, Spencer Bivens, Matt Gage (who right now is the only healthy lefty reliever on the 40-man roster) and…four others? Choose from NRIs like Michael Fulmer, Kilian, Will Bednar, Sanchez (a lefty) or 40-man options like McDonald, Carson Seymour, Keaton Winn, Tristan Beck, or even Blade Tidwell. I have some guesses (they’re on my ballot) but honestly no idea how this is all going to play out. I still wish the Giants would sign and/or trade for another veteran bullpen arm. It really feels like they need one(s).

OK, that leads us to…

 

Reminder: My26ManGuysâ„¢ Deadline is March 11!

As HaakAway has been sharing on the board, it’s time for our annual contest in which we try to pick the 26-man roster that will line up on Opening Night (March 25 vs Yankees at Oracle Park). The winner gets bragging rights and a commemorative pin.

  • To enter, follow this link: https://forms.gle/n8WyRasZ42wdWQVi7
  • Once you enter, save the email confirmation that follows because that allows you to get back to your ballot and make edits.
  • This year’s (revised) deadline is March 11.

 

Today’s Split-Squad Games

Giants at Diamondbacks, 12:10 p.m., Salt River Fields at Talking Stick

Audio on MLB.com (Dbacks broadcast)

JT Brubaker vs Kohl Drake

Rangers at Giants, 12:05 p.m., Scottsdale Stadium

Radio: KNBR, TV: NBCS-BA, MLBN

Jacob Latz vs Carson Whisenhunt

The Leftys, including BrotherLefty, will be at the home game today. Big day for Whisenhunt, who could be in line for an early back-to-AAA cut if he doesn’t right his ship quickly. Enjoy the game(s)! Lefty out.