by DrLefty

Many of you know that MrLefty, who in real life is a tax attorney, is also a talented singer-songwriter. One of his observations about songwriting is that a well-written song can mean many different things to various people. To give two recent examples, last year when I was counting down the days to my retirement, the song that spoke to me and that I had on repeat was “Already Gone” by the Eagles. This year, as we were getting ready to move from a top-floor condo that faces west (great for sunsets, pretty hot in July) to a mid-century modern home with a small grove of redwood trees in the backyard, the song I kept playing was “Cool Change” by the Little River Band. Now, I know perfectly well that “Already Gone” is not about retirement and “Cool Change” is not about acquiring redwood trees to shade you in the hot Davis summer, but as the Mr says–a good song can speak to you in various ways.

I woke up this morning thinking about what I’d write for Out of Left Field and was honestly at a loss. We’re not even to the All-Star break, and I feel like there’s nothing left to say about this year’s putrid excuse for a San Francisco Giants team. There have been other weeks that seemed pretty bad when I sat down on Saturday morning to write about it, but this week seems especially dismal. The Giants came off their first successful home stand since April, winning their series against the A’s and the Braves, and headed off on the road to play the mediocre Diamondbacks and the lowly Rockies. So far they’ve lost three of the four games, and none of those losses were really even competitive. Even the game they won, which featured bright spots from Trevor McDonald, Heliot Ramos, and Victor Bericoto, almost turned into a disastrous loss thanks to the tender mercies of Ryan Walker (0 outs, 4 runs allowed). Yesterday we heard the happy news that Logan Webb won NL Pitcher of the Month for June, so he promptly went out and had the worst start of his career last night. And so it goes.

So far all my song references have been buried deep back in the 60s-70s, so to be a bit more contemporary, I’ll cite Taylor Swift (the new Mrs. Travis Kelce) in saying that it’s a “Cruel Summer.” (OK, it’s only actually been summer on the calendar for two weeks, so maybe it’s been a “cruel spring,” but chances are that the summer isn’t going to be any better for the Giants, and as I said last week, it could well get worse.)

The Giants are not giving us much entertainment (or me much inspiration) these days, nor am I feeling especially moved by today being the 250th anniversary of the American Declaration of Independence. When I think about this country at this point in time, I have the same thoughts as I do about the Giants:

There’s something happening here

What it is ain’t exactly clear…

There’s battle lines being drawnNobody’s right if everybody’s wrong
[…]
What a field-day for the heatA thousand people in the streetSinging songs and a-carrying signsMostly say hooray for our side

As with the Eagles last year and Little River Band this year, Buffalo Springfield (that’s who’s pictured above) is speaking to me right now.

 

The Giants and the 4th of July

I do have a few memories that I associate with the 4th of July when it comes to the Giants, some more fun than others.

July 4, 2000

The Giants were in their first season in their new ballpark on the shores of McCovey Cove. They were having a mediocre year. MrLefty and I and the kids went to the first game of a day-night doubleheader against the Rockies, which the Giants won. We left the park and went to a holiday BBQ at my mom’s house, and the Giants won the night game, sweeping the doubleheader. From that point on, they were unstoppable and ended up winning the NL West that year. We took full credit for our timely intervention.

July 4, 2010

We returned home after several weeks abroad. The Giants played poorly while we were gone. On July 3, while we were on our final flight home, they ralled at Coors Field against Ubaldo Jimenez, who was untouchable at that point. We felt that our return to the U.S. had sparked their rally and win. The next day, though, they lost a 15-inning game, and one of the most memorable moments was when manager Bruce Bochy pinch-ran for Buster Posey with Eli Whiteside. The game went on and on, and Posey’s bat was missed and the Giants lost (he was NL Rookie of the Month in July 2010). Bochy got skewered on the airwaves the next day for removing Posey (who was just 23 years old and hadn’t had his awful ankle injury yet) for a backup catcher. I’m pretty sure he never did that again. That season turned out pretty well, too.

July 4, 2024

I actually have no idea what the Giants did that day, but we went to Taylor Swift’s Eras Tour in Amsterdam with our daughter.

The Lefty family at the Eras Tour in Amsterdam

Honorable Mention: July 4, 1983

Future #ForeverGiant Dave Righetti pitched a no-hitter for the Yankees, their first since Don Larsen’s 1956 perfect game in the World Series.

 

One Giant Shout-Out

Casey Schmitt, who’s playing 3B with Matt Chapman out, made an amazing play in the bottom of the first last night, which temporarily helped Webb limit the damage. Even though the game continued to get further out of hand–the Giants lost 15-3, and my only question is why Christian Koss didn’t get to pitch–that play is worth celebrating. When Dave Flemming, who’s watched a lot of baseball, calls it “one of the greatest plays I’ve ever seen,” you need to celebrate it. Hunter Pence also pointed out that Bryce Eldridge made a fine pick at the back end of the play at 1B.

For what it’s worth(!), Bob Nightengale said recently that the Giants would like to trade Luis Arraez, Robbie Ray, and Chapman by the deadline. There are several roadblocks to trading Chapman, including his full no-trade clause (which he may not be eager to waive, given that he and his wife are expecting their second child any day now), but “who would play third” is not one of the barriers. Chapman is the best defensive 3B I’ve ever watched as a Giants fan, and nearly all of his value these days is in his glove, but Schmitt is an extremely credible replacement.  Per Fangraphs, Schmitt has a 1.4 WAR for the year, while Chapman is at 1.3, and that’s not even a fair comparison. Schmitt has played 23 games at DH, 30 games in LF, and the rest divided among four different infield positions. Meanwhile, Chapman has been comfortably (and deservedly) parked at Schmitt’s best natural position. Let Schmitt play one position regularly and combine it with his bat, and he’s not only younger and (much) cheaper than Chapman, he’s actually more valuable.

I think it’s probably more likely that Arraez will get traded and Schmitt will become the everyday 2B, but the play last night reminds us of what we could (still) have if Schmitt were take over at the hot corner.

 

A Few Random Observations, For What (They’re) Worth

  • I’m sure I’ve mentioned this before, but the Giants’ bullpen really, really, really sucks. Jeff Young, an astute commenter about the Giants, tweeted this during last night’s game.

I honestly would be fine with getting rid of almost every reliever on the current roster. Maybe I’d keep Caleb Kilian (but not as a closer). Other than that? Nope. First out the door, if I were in charge, would be Walker and Sam Hentges, both of whom have been just awful. Replace them all with whomever from Sacramento, Richmond, the waiver wire, the Mexican League, the KBO–I don’t care. Couldn’t be worse. Might even be better.

  • Rafael Devers is actually hitting pretty well these days. His homer last night happened long after we stopped watching the game, but he’s up to 16, which ties Schmitt for the team lead. His OPS for the season is now .775, which is still below his career average (.849), but not bad at all. Over the past seven games, he’s hit four homers and has a .917 OPS. As I mentioned last week, he’s on pace for a career high in strikeouts, so there’s also that. He’s obviously still a good hitter, but he’s too expensive to trade, and there you have it.
  • Jonah Cox played some 2B last night for the second time this week. Both times he’s actually made a pretty good play. I read that he’s excited to be getting infield opportunities and aspires to be a super-utility player, a la Ben Zobrist, Chris Taylor, or…Casey Schmitt.
  • Gavin Kilen, the Giants’ #4 prospect, won Northwest League Player of the Week honors and was named to the Futures Game, along with #5 prospect and Eugene teammate Dakota Jordan.
  • The All-Star Game selection show is tonight at 4:30 and will be televised on Fox. The Giants have to have one representative. Will it be Arraez? Schmitt? Webb? Jung Hoo Lee? I’m rooting for it to be Arraez. He deserves a lot of credit and recognition for reinventing himself this season. Ron Washington deserves a lot of credit for that, too.

 

Tonight’s Game

Giants at Rockies, 5:40 p.m. at Coors Field

Robbie “Trade Bait” Ray (7-6, 3.39 ERA) vs. Sean Sullivan* (0-2, 8.64 ERA)

*The original starter, Tomayo Sugano, was scratched. I’m sure the Giants will be fine against a soft-tossing lefty they’ve never seen before.

 

 

We’ll let Buffalo Springfield take us out today. Lefty out.