by DrLefty

So I was all ready to add my own opinions about this week’s trade deadline sell-off to the ones Greek Giant already shared here and here, but then I went to last night’s game at Citi Field and decided I’d rather talk about that. I’ll get to a few big-picture thoughts before I finish up.

As most of you know, yesterday was my birthday (also NatesFanMom’s bday, Madison Bumgarner’s, and Jerry Garcia’s [RIP]), and this year was a big one (let’s call it my “Medicare birthday”). We didn’t get to celebrate our 60th birthdays in any kind of style because of COVID, so this year we did it up pretty big. MrL’s birthday in May involved a Giants game on his actual birthday on Saturday. (We got the puffer vest giveaways and saw Wilmer Flores‘s walk-off walk against former A’s closer Mason Miller.)

For my birthday, we looked at the Giants’ schedule and saw they’d be in New York playing the Mets. We love New York and travel here every couple of years to see shows, go to museums, walk around Central Park, and eat good food. So here we are. We’re staying at the OG St. Regis. (NOTE: The stay is on Bonvoy points. I’m a very savvy points-and-miles traveler.) The St. Regis is famous among other things for having invented the Bloody Mary. Their most famous version is called the Red Snapper. At breakfast this morning we ordered a couple, and we told the server who brought them that we’d had them in San Francisco but wanted to come to the O.G. St. Regis and have O.G. Bloody Marys. He was so pleased by this that not only did he comp our breakfast cocktails, but a half hour later, room service brought us more Bloody Marys. So yes, if you’re keeping score at home, I’m composing this week’s version of OOLF while on my second Bloody Mary. (And no, this is not a typical pattern for me. At home MrL makes me a quadruple-shot latte to have while I write my column, but I’m always sober. So we’ll see how this goes.)

 

Going to the Game

We took the subway to the 7 train to get to Citi Field from our Midtown Manhattan hotel, and let me tell you, that was a piece of cake. It cost $2.90 per person for each segment, you just swipe your phone, and off you go. We rode about four stops on the M line, transferred to the 7, and after about five stops that lets you off right outside the ballpark. The trains were full but not ridiculously crowded. The whole process took about 40 minutes, tops. Much better than paying $100 for an Uber and sitting in traffic.

Our tickets allowed us access to a field club, so we went to have a pregame libation. An usher named Gary messed with me by saying that we couldn’t go to the club because we had Giants gear on, but I told him it was my birthday and he said it would be OK. We walked by Larry Baer in the club, and MrL said, casually, “Hey Larry,” like he knew him, and Larry said, “Hey!” (probably wondering who the hell we were). We had a drink and chatted with a bartender who was a lot more interested in comparing notes with us about ballparks he’d visited around the country (loves Oracle in “San Fran”) than working.

Our seats were about six rows behind the visitors’ dugout, so we had a good view of the players. We were also mostly surrounded by boisterous Giants fans who seemed empowered by having other Faithful around them, so if you heard any “Let’s Go Giants” or “Jung Hoo Lee” chants on the broadcast, that was probably our section. Here are a few photos.

 

Tom Terrific statue, which you see as you exit the train station to head into the park.

Larry Baer (navy jacket next to the dugout)

View from our seats

Lineup photo on the video board

 

We’d been to Citi Field once before, back in 2013 on the Finnerty’s bus, and we like it way better than the new version of Yankee Stadium, which we’ve also been to a couple of times. It’s a very user-friendly ballpark–easy to get to on public transit, good signage, comfortable, excellent video screens. (The folks at Oracle could take a note on how they present information at Citi Field. I find our video screen overly busy and the information hard to process.) They have a lot of fun entertainment stuff going on between innings, too. Oh, and it was fireworks night, and those of you who’ve been to River Cats games with me know that IΒ love fireworks, so it was all good!

As you’re probably aware, the ballpark is on a direct flight path from LaGuardia, so there are a lot of “flyovers.” You couldn’t even hear Robbie Ray grunt.

 

The Game

I read Andrew Baggarly’s description and can confirm: hyped-up Mets fans all excited to greet their new acquisitions, the tense excitement at the end when everyone knew the home team was about to walk it off. That’s what it felt like. But observing the Giants–and we were close enough to the dugout that Willy Adames smiled at us during some of our chants–they seemed calm and collected and like they were trying to pump each other up. I saw Adames walking out to the field with his arm around Rafael Devers after one of his several strikeouts. I saw Matt Chapman with his arm around Grant McCray after he got turned into a grease spot by new reliever Ryan Helsley. The veteran leaders were trying to pull everyone together.

Robbie Ray was great and just seemed like he was completely in control. I’m not holding a solo homer to Pete Alonso against him. He gave them seven strong innings and left with the lead, and that’s a tough lineup. The Mets did a nice video tribute to Jose Butto at the start of the game, and I was pretty worried about bringing him in with the game on the line in what was sure to be an emotional moment, but he did OK, too. Ryan Walker looked sharp, but let’s talk about that pop-up to end the inning. Matt Chapman ran for that ball like he was trying for a Pick-6, and Patrick Bailey was smirking as he walked off the field. In real time from our angle, it looked like Bailey’s ball and that he had it, but Chapman wasn’t leaving anything to chance. How did it look to y’all on TV? Did Bailey lose the ball in the lights and Chapman saved the day, or was Chapman over-amped?

I feel like maybe some of the problem with the Giants over these last couple of months, when they regressed from playoff contenders to trade deadline sellers, was that if anything, they were playingΒ too tight, not lackadaisical or unfocused. Trying too hard after Buster said “It’s time to go” and obtained Devers.

Remember my “Magic 8 ball” column five weeks ago? Well, here was one of the questions and the “8-ball’s answer”:

    • Will Camilo Doval still be the closer in September?
      • Response: My sources say no

(DrL’s take:Β Randy Rodriguez, come on down!)

Our new closer showed a lot of poise, and for a young guy who’s supposed to be pretty unassuming and sweet-natured, got his revenge over Ronny Mauricio, who took him deep into the Cove last weekend and then twirled, preened, and pranced around the bases like he’d just won a playoff game instead of knocking in the tying run in the seventh inning in July. Randy was all “oh, yeah? How about some triple digits, Dbag?” And the hyped-up Mets fans all ready to celebrate a walk-off slunk out sullenly while we Giants fans enjoyed my birthday fireworks.

I noticed a little subtle fist-pump from both Rodriguez and Bailey after that one. I thought Randy really showed some stones in that at-bat. Just went right after him with gas, no nibbling. Seems like a certain new Yankees closer could learn a few things. (Seriously, I wish Camilo well, and for his sake I’m glad that meltdown happened in Miami and not Yankee Stadium. I have nothing against him, but he stressed me out and I’m kind of relieved that he’s gone.)

The Leftys are now 5-0 at Giants games this year. Maybe if we’d gone to some games in June and July, the Giants wouldn’t have been sellers at the deadline. I guess we’ll never know.

 

Some Big-Picture Thoughts, In No Particular Order

  1. The Giants obtained a left-handed hitting AAA outfielder, Drew Gilbert, and a starting pitcher, Blade Tidwell, from the Mets in the Tyler Rogers trade. Instead of promoting either of them immediately, the Giants promoted McCray and Kai-Wei Teng, who will start today’s game. I feel like the message is that guys who’ve been doing the work in AAA should get their opportunity, not whatever new toy the front office just got from some other team. This is the opposite of how the previous regime would have handled things. Exhibit A is when A.J. Pollock and Mark Mathias, obtained at the 2023 trade deadline, leapfrogged Heliot Ramos and Tyler Fitzgerald, homegrown prospects who were playing well in AAA. Neither veteran lasted two weeks as a Giant, and in 2024, Ramos was an All-Star and Fitzgerald was NL Rookie of the Month for July. Now, McCray looked beyond overmatched last night, striking out twice in six pitches against two All-Star closers throwing 100 MPH, and Gilbert may be along shortly, same with Tidwell. But this is the time of the season for the Giants to look at young players and see what they have for the future, and the ‘he was here first, so he gets the first shot” philosophy (other things being relatively equal)Β  resonates with me, and I bet it does for the guys in AAA and AA.
  2. The biggest question for the immediate future is how the Giants will cover the bullpen innings previously manned by Rogers and Doval–specifically Rogers. They still have some good pieces in Walker, Joey Lucchesi, Erik Miller when he returns (hopefully), the new guy Butto, and obviously Rodriguez. I find myself wondering if Hayden Birdsong’s ticket back to the big leagues this season is in the bullpen, where he was crazy good early in the season. It might not be the worst idea in the world to help him re-set. They can always re-evaluate things before next season.
  3. I’m intrigued for Teng’s start today and Carson Whisenhunt’s tomorrow. It was easy to be sour about Whisenhunt’s first start in the middle of an ugly losing streak, but big picture, he wasn’t bad, and it was encouraging to see him bear down and throw three more solid innings after a messy second inning. He left tied after five innings, and while he wasn’t stellar, he wasn’t awful, either.
  4. Most observers have described the Giants’ return for Doval as “underwhelming” or “disappointing.” Well…we’ll see. The most immediately intriguing prospect is the AAA catcher, Jesus Rodriguez (we could have an all-Rodriguez battery closing out games!), and I’m actually going to be surprised if we don’t see him sooner rather than later. Nothing against Andrew Knizner, who I think has done fine as the backup catcher, but–the rest of this season is about looking toward the future, and Knizner ain’t it (and neither is Tom Murphy, remember him?).

Before I close out, BrotherLefty has some thoughts he’s asked me to share.

I am increasingly convinced that BoMel and most of his coaching staff must go, too. Even though they picked up his option, they can still afford to let him go financially. This year’s failure is a team-wide issue, but I have no confidence in the current coaching staff. He may be a nice guy and a good β€œbaseball” guy, but that doesn’t count for shit unless you’re winning.

(I’m not sure where BrotherL got his potty mouth. Certainly not from his big sister!)

I don’t disagree with his thoughts. The systemwide failure seems to be as bewildering to Buster Posey as it is to us, and at some point, you have to ask if the preparation and the accountability issues can be attributed to the manager and coaching staff. I’d add to BrotherL’s thoughts that, if I were in charge, which I absolutely am not, I’d be looking at overhauling the entire drafting and developing infrastructure. Other than creating a position at the top of that pyramid for Randy Winn and moving Zack Minasian out of pro scouting into the GM role, that leadership structure has stayed the same. I’d be asking questions about that after this year. To give just one example, just look over the Yolo Causeway at the A’s. They produce one stud young player after another. Meanwhile, A.J. Preller on the Padres just flipped the #3 prospect in baseball to get one of those A’s studs, Mason Miller. We never have guys like that. Why not?

 

Finally

I can’t leave this turbulent week without saying a few words about #ForeverGiant Mike Yastrzemski. I’ve loved him ever since he came up in 2019. There was just something about his story that grabbed me–the combination of being a legend’s grandson but buried for six years in the minors by the Orioles before the Giants finally gave him a chance. We happened to be in Baltimore to witness Yaz’s first major league home run, and I was with other TWGers at Oracle Park that July when he hit his first of five (5!) career walk-off homers. I was at his bobblehead day in 2021, one of the first games after COVID where they could fill the ballpark. The bobblehead is still sitting on my desk at home.

Yaz was a pro, a great guy, and a credit to the organization. He has to be considered one of Farhan Zaidi’s greatest success stories. I’ll miss him and I wish him well. Here’s a compilation of the walk-off homers.

And here’s his classy goodbye message:

I understand why the Giants traded Yaz, I don’t disagree with the thinking, and they may even have gotten a decent lottery ticket in return in young A-ball pitcher Yunior Marte the Second (the other one was traded for Erik Miller a couple of years ago!). But I’m still sad to see Yaz go. Tyler Rogers, too. Good Giants, both.

 

Tonight’s Game

Giants at Mets, Citi Field, 1:10 p.m.Β 

Kai-Wei Teng (0-0, 0.00 ERA) vs. Kodai Senga (7-3, 2.00 ERA)

We will not be out at the park tonight, but stevek and his Mrs. will. We are planning to watch the game from the new Finnerty’s and then head to a Broadway show tonight. I’ll take pictures at Finnerty’s and post them here tomorrow.

Hang in there, Giants fans. There are still things to cheer for and be hopeful about. Lefty out.