Giants catcher Buster Posey reflects in the dugout after Bobby Evans is fired as GM in 2018

by DrLefty

There’s not much Giants news this week, and the playoffs are grossing me out, so today I thought I’d share some musings about the possible direction(s) for our beloved team. We don’t know much about what the weeks and months ahead might hold, but we do know one thing for sure: There is regime change. And that happens for a reason. So where will the Giants go next? Will they forge a path similar to the one that recently deposed President of Baseball Operations (POBO) Farhan Zaidi was treading? Will they go “back to the future”–return to what was working before Zaidi (until it didn’t anymore)? Or is there a Door #3–a new way forward that reflects neither the most recent tenure of Zaidi nor the previous tenure of GMs Brian Sabean and Bobby Evans?

Let’s look and see if there are any clues.

  1. The Giants are going to hire a new GM. New POBO Buster Posey didn’t share much in the way of specifics at his press conference on October 1. It’s not surprising–he’d only just gotten the gig, the playoffs are still in progress, and there’s a lot he either doesn’t know yet or can’t/won’t say yet. But he did say right away that Zaidi’s GM, Pete Putila, is out after two years of service and will be “reassigned” (which is what they said about Bobby Evans in 2018, but we’ll get back to that). Before we get to the rumors about who the new GM could be, let’s pause for a minute on Putila’s “reassignment.” Since Posey mentioned more than once that day that they’d look for a GM with a “scouting background,” it might seem surprising that Putlia, who was hired from the Astros organization and had served as director of player development there, would be ousted so quickly. But perhaps it’s as simple as “Putila never actually worked as a scout.” Putila’s removal may also simply signal that the new POBO wants to pick his own right-hand person, not someone left over from the previous regime.
  2. The Giants’ GM interview list may include some familiar names. As already noted, Posey emphasized that the new GM would have a strong scouting background and also be “relatable.” Some names that have emerged include inside candidate Jeremy Shelley, who was mentioned specifically by Posey in his press conference. Shelley has been in the Giants’ front office since 1994 and most recently has been serving as assistant GM to Putila. It’s also been reported that the Giants asked for and received permission from the A’s to interview their assistant GM, Billy Owens. Owens, whom the Giants interviewed before hiring Putila, seems like the perfect fit: he played baseball professionally (six years as a minor leaguer), became a minor league coach, was a scout, a scouting coordinator, and eventually director of player personnel. Like the Astros, the A’s have a long history of drafting and developing talented young players. It also would not hurt that Owens has relationships with manager Bob Melvin and some of the coaches and with new face of the franchise Matt Chapman. Alex Pavlovic profiled ten potential GM candidates, several of whom were also interviewed by Zaidi in previous rounds (when Scott Harris was hired in 2020 and Putila before the 2023 season).
  3. Back to the future? Pavlovic’s article also mentioned Brian Sabean and Bobby Evans as being in the mix, and Posey himself mentioned Sabean’s name. Sabean is still employed by the Yankees and has another year on his contract, but it sounds like he’s a bit wistful for the Bay Area and the Giants, so he might welcome an opportunity to work with Posey. As for Evans, Pavlovic noted that even when Sabean was in charge, Evans did a lot of negotiating of contracts with players and their agents, a skill set that Posey doesn’t (yet) have. By the way, I’d vaguely assumed that the “reassigned” Evans was still somewhere around with the Giants, but it sounds like he hasn’t worked in baseball since being fired as GM in 2018 and would like to find his way back.
  4. What about the manager? Melvin was hired by Zaidi, and it’s fair to say that his first year in his dream job didn’t go as he’d hoped. Many fans wondered if he’d be shown the door along with Zaidi, but Melvin was sitting at Posey’s right during that October 1 press conference, so that question was quickly answered. As news of Zaidi’s dismissal began settling in, stories began to emerge about what a micro-manager Zaidi was, how even a respected veteran manager like Melvin didn’t get a free hand, and how Posey was unlikely to be that kind of POBO. Even though Melvin is “new” to the Giants as a manager, he feels like an old-school hire: not only did he grow up in the Bay Area as a Giants fan, play for Cal, and play for the Giants, he also brought a beloved former Giant, third base coach Matt Williams, along with him.  A former catcher like Posey himself and like beloved manager Bruce Bochy, Melvin just seems like a fit for the “new sheriff in town”–ironically even more so than he did for Zaidi, with whom he’d worked when he managed the A’s for 10 years.
  5. Coaching staff changes? This week it was announced that pitching coach Bryan Price decided to retire (or re-retire). It doesn’t appear that he was forced out, and the Giants almost immediately promoted J.P. Martinez, who’s been an assistant pitching coach for the past four years, to Price’s position. Accentuating the positive, the Giants’ tweet announcing Martinez’s promotion highlighted that over the past four seasons, the Giants have had the fourth-best team ERA (3.80) in the major leagues. However, as Grant Brisbee put it, the Giants’ pitching was “an underrated weakness” of the desultory 2024 team that got Zaidi fired (19th in MLB in team ERA). It’s hard to peg whether that underwhelming performance in what was expected to be a strength of the team can be blamed on Price, on Zaidi’s team construction, or simply on bad luck. As Brisbee pointed out, Martinez has now worked for two pitching coaches (Andrew Bailey and Price), two managers (Melvin and Gabe Kapler), and now two POBOs. So his elevation represents continuity and stability for a pitching staff that needs to be better in 2025. The other shoe to drop, though, is the hitting coaches. Going into the 2024 season, Justin Viele (who joined the Giants when Kapler was hired before the 2020 season) was sharing the hitting coach job with new hire Pat Burrell, while Pedro Guerrero, who was hired before the 2022 season, also continued as assistant hitting coach. It is fair to say that the Giants underperformed at the plate the past several years and that their approach in general seems to have been disproven. Will Posey replace some or all of the hitting coaches?
  6. Player retentions? After he hires a GM, Posey and his new lieutenant will have to make some decisions over the next few weeks. The first is whether to bring back three previous Willie Mac Award winners: Mike Yastrzemski (2020), LaMonte Wade Jr. (2021), and Wilmer Flores (2022). Yaz and Wade are both arbitration-eligible. As for Flores, he has a $3.5 mil player option for next year that he seems almost sure to exercise. If he does, the Giants’ only decision will be whether to keep him on the roster, bring him to spring training, and see how he looks after knee surgery this year. If he declines the option, the Giants could exercise their $8.5 mil team option to retain Flores for next year, which seems highly unlikely.
  7. More “retentions”? The heavy lifting–signing Chapman to an extension–is already done. But what about Blake Snell, who is certain to opt out of his second year with the Giants? Will they make a serious effort to re-sign Snell, who’s signaled openness to returning to the Giants? A lesser question is whether they will pony up arbitration money for erstwhile All-Star closer Camilo Doval. But I don’t think that’s a serious question. Doval is too young and too talented to give up on (yet), though I wouldn’t rule out a trade now that he’s lost his closer spot to Ryan Walker. A different kind of “retention” involves Robbie Ray, who will likely opt into the final two years of his contract.
  8. Bringing back old friends? If the Giants don’t bring back Snell (either because they don’t try to or because he chooses to go elsewhere), it could be argued that they should pursue another free agent pitcher.  Starting the season with a rotation of Logan Webb, Ray, Jordan Hicks, Kyle Harrison, and other youngsters (Landon Roupp, Hayden Birdsong, etc.) sounds an awful lot like the plan for 2024 that didn’t work. If the Giants decide Snell is either too rich for their blood (and/or too flaky) and that St. Mary’s alum Corbin Burnes is also out of their price range, could they pursue old friends like Sean Manaea or Alex Cobb? Manaea, who’s had a terrific season with the Mets, may finally have set himself up for the longer-term deal that’s eluded him the last two off-seasons. Indeed, it could be argued he’ll be the third-best free agent starter after Snell and Burnes. He could be a good Webb-adjacent option for the rotation. Cobb, who’s near/at the end of his career, could probably be gotten on a short-term deal, and he was well-liked as a Giant and could provide some veteran rotation depth. Another old friend whom I fantasize about bringing back is Joey Bart. I’m guessing the Pirates would like to keep him, but he will be eligible for arbitration this year, and the Pirates are on a budget. If Buster wants to right that wrong and offer an interesting prospect package for Bart…maybe?
  9. New blood needed? As I noted above, one could argue that the Giants need a new hitting coach(es), but even more than that–they need some new hitters. The obvious holes are at shortstop and possibly first base. (I’m assuming here that Tyler Fitzgerald will be penciled in for one of the middle infield positions.) If Posey et al. decide to let both Wade and Flores go, they could pursue a first base upgrade to bridge the gap to top prospect Bryce Eldridge. The two serious upgrades on the market are Mets’ star Pete Alonso and the Diamondbacks’ Christian Walker. Assuming that the Giants don’t want to block Eldridge, who finished last season in AAA, two more likely options are Carlos Santana or Paul Goldschmidt. Santana is almost 39 and Goldschmidt will be 37 for next season. Santana had a better year at the plate with the Twins than Goldschmidt had with the Cardinals, but both hit over 20 homers, and Goldy is a four-time Gold Glove winner at 1B. IF the Giants make a quick strike to sign either Santana or Goldschmidt to a short-term deal, I could see them non-tendering Wade and/or DFA’ing Flores (if he picks up his player option). As for shortstop, in the same way that it seemed inevitable last year that Chapman would become a Giant, it seems similarly inevitable that Ha-Seong Kim will join his good buddy Jung Hoo Lee and his former manager, Melvin, in San Francisco. (Yes, I know Kim had shoulder surgery, and that’s not a good quality in a shortstop. But he’s only expected to miss the first month or so of next season, and the Giants can handle things in the meantime with some combination of Fitzgerald, Casey Schmitt, or others.)
  10. Lost-and-found prospects. I was going to make my tenth point about bringing back long-time PA announcer Renel Brooks-Moon, but that’s probably not really a “baseball operations” call, and this is more important, anyway. Posey and his advisors will have to decide what to do about mishandled top prospects Marco Luciano and Luis Matos. Much has been written, including in this space, about the strange odyssey regarding Luciano in particular over the past year. It’s hard to peg whether the experts in the room think Luciano himself is the problem or whether the Zaidi regime has grossly mismanaged his career for years now (when you consider that scouts have been saying since he was a teenager that there was no way he could stick at shortstop). Now it’s hard to guess whether they’ll do with Luciano–trade him, which would be selling (way) low? Park him in AAA for a full season to focus mainly on hitting? Try again to make him a middle infielder? Matos, it would seem, still has a path to the big leagues next season in the outfield, though with Lee, possibly Yaz, and Heliot Ramos all looking like everyday players, he’d either be a fourth outfielder or an injury replacement.

 

Analysis

It’s really early to read the tea leaves, but the message thus far seems to be stability and leaning into approaches that have worked in the past. I don’t think either Sabean or Evans will become GM again, but it sounds possible and likely that one or both of them will return in an advisory role (Sabean perhaps after this year when his contract with the Yankees ends). My initial guess is that Billy Owens will get the job and Jeremy Shelley will continue in his role given his extensive institutional memory. I also think it’s possible that all the hitting coaches get one more year. My sense is that Posey really respects Bob Melvin, and Melvin’s on the record (from a Baggarly article late in the season) as saying that his coaches have worked hard and done a great job and shouldn’t take the fall for how the season went. Here’s a quote from Melvin from that article:

…I think the group of hitting instructors we have, the three of them, do a fantastic job. Each do different things. You have the experience of Pat Burrell, with what he’s accomplished in the big leagues and the mindset of what it takes to be successful. You have Justin Viele, who knows every number, every dynamic, every swing plane. He’s so well versed. Petey Guerrero complements them, and as a Spanish speaker, he’s been fantastic with our Latin guys.

“I know our numbers don’t look great, but it’s not for a lack of preparation and work from our hitting guys.”

My guess is that, if Melvin wants his trio of hitting coaches back, Buster will defer to him.

Regarding the player-related questions, I believe that Yaz will be back, partly because he’s the kind of thoughtful, articulate leader that Buster himself was, and you figure that Posey would recognize that. (The other part is that Yaz has earned his final year of arbitration. He had an above-average OPS+ of 110, is a Gold Glove finalist in right field, and hit more home runs [18] than he has since 2021.) This is different from Flores, who is also a good clubhouse leader especially for Latin players. Wilmer had an excellent year in 2023 (especially compared with, well, everyone else on the Giants) but fell off a cliff in 2024. If he picks up his player option, for $3.5 mil, they might bring him to spring training. Zaidi probably wouldn’t have done it because he would want the roster spot for the next (Connor) Joe Schmoe (McCarthy), but Buster might look at the intangibles that Flores brings and decide that’s a bargain for $3.5 million.

I also think that Buster didn’t dig Snell’s act and would rather look elsewhere if he’s going to spend $150-200 mil on a starting pitcher–and that’s an IF. Buster was around when the Giants built a 3-in-5 dynasty around homegrown young pitching and a lights-out bullpen. While Barry Zito (a pricey free agent in his day) had his incredible #RallyZito moment of redemption in 2012, it’s worth remembering that he didn’t work well with Buster and had not-Buster “personal catchers” in 2011-12. But I could totally see them bringing Manaea and/or Cobb back into the fold for the reasons outlined above.

As for Luciano, I have no idea what Buster thinks about him. I just kind of feel like there could be a Luciano + Doval package to trade for…something. (A starting pitcher? A first baseman? A shortstop? Something.) One of the biggest differences between Sabean and Zaidi is that Zaidi never really traded prospects for major leaguers, with the rental of Kris Bryant in 2021 being the most notable exception. Sabean? He did it ALL THE TIME. Tim Alderson for Freddy Sanchez. John Bowker and Joe Martinez for Javi Lopez. Charlie Culberson for Marco Scutaro. Tommy Joseph (and Nate Schierholtz) for Hunter Pence. Edwin Escobar and Heath Hembree for Jake Peavy. I expect to see more Sabean-like moves and less Zaidi-like prospect-hugging in the Posey era. (The ironic thing was that Zaidi hugged his prospects and then mishandled them. See Bart, Joey, and Luciano, Marco. SMH)

Many weeks of speculation lie ahead, but when I look at what Buster himself has told us combined with what makes sense, my conclusion is that his regime will resemble that of Sabean more than it will that of Zaidi. And I say thank goodness for that. Lefty out.