Photo credit: @SFGiantsΒ
by DrLefty
In last week’s Out of Left Field, I shamed the Giants for “breaking faith” with their faithful fans by being so inactive during this offseason and gently mocked a line from an Andrew Baggarly article saying that the Giants were, on January 24, “poised to engage” with free agent outfielderΒ Harrison Bader.Β Well, about 48 hours after I posted, the news broke that the Giants had indeed “engaged” Bader’s services, to the tune of a two-year, $20.5M contract. I am certain that my words pushed the effort over the goal line.
That’s my story, and I’m sticking to it.
Yesterday, the deal became official. (Bader had to pass his physical, and after the December 2022 Carlos Correa debacle, no Giants fan will ever hear the phrase “pending a physical” in the same way. The Giants also had to clear a 40-man roster spot, which they did on Thursday by trading pitcher Kai-Wei Teng to the Miami Marlins for a minor league catcher/outfielder and some international free agent money.) Once the announcement had been made, President of Baseball Operations Buster Posey met with reporters, and in the afternoon, Bader himself did. Let’s look at the signing, including some of Bader’s remarks, add some detail from Posey’s comments, and then talk about where the Giants might head next (other than Scottsdale, which is right around the corner–tomorrow is February!).
Why Bader is a Great Fit
Let’s get this out of the way. Bader is a glove-first outfielder. His career OPS+ is 96, slightly below league average. However, last year was his best offensive year (117 OPS+, 17 homers, between two teams, Minnesota and Philadelphia). He also struck out way more than he had in recent years, so he should fit right in. It’s hard to say how much he will add to the Giants’ lineup, but it is encouraging that in 18 career games at Oracle Park, he has hit four homers there. In fact, his first career homer was there, off Johnny Cueto in 2017.
Here’s the thing, though. The Giants already have a good lineup, at least on paper. Bader won’t hurt it, and he will likely be better offensively than any of the other in-house options for that open outfield spot (Drew Gilbert, Luis Matos, Grant McCray, Jerar Encarnacion).Β But that’s not why the Giants got him. They pursued him all offseason–i.e., they didn’t just “poise to engage” on January 24–because he’s arguably the best defensive centerfielder in the game right now. The only CF with more Outs Above Average (OAA) since Bader’s debut in 2017 is the now-retired Kevin Kiermaier, a four-time Gold Glover. Bader won a Gold Glove in CF in 2021 while with the Cardinals. Over his career, he has 77 OAA, 67 of those in CF, and 67 Defensive Runs Saved (DRS), of which 51 were in CF. To contextualize this further, Bader, until 2024, didn’t play all that many games each year. He had various nagging injuries, but in his meeting with reporters yesterday explained that he’d had hernia surgery after the 2023 season that resolved some issues. He then played in 143 games in 2024 and 146 games in 2025. So (a) there’s reason to hope that he’ll stay on the field in 2026 and (b) those gaudy OAA/DRS numbers are even more impressive considering the relatively small sample size of games for a guy who’s been around since 2017.
So Bader is a terrific defensive outfielder, and the Giants, by several metrics, had the worst outfield defense in the majors over the last two seasons. Once the news about Bader broke, the speculation immediately was that he’d be the main CF, withΒ Jung Hoo Lee moving to RF, and Posey confirmed as much yesterday. Posey added that he and GM Zack Minasian had spoken to Lee about this already and that he was “great about it.” Lee was a poor CF (-18 DRS last year, which is Denard Span territory), but there’s reason to believe he might be an excellent RF–he has speed, athleticism, and a strong arm. The ground that he and Bader can cover should also take some pressure off Heliot Ramos,Β who was…also not a good OF last season. Further, the addition of Bader allows the Giants to use Gilbert as a fourth outfielder and defensive replacement, which should take the pressure off Gilbert, who is just barely past rookie status, to produce as an everyday member of the lineup. In other words, this one move of signing Bader substantially improves the entire picture in the outfield.
The final reason why Bader is a good addition is his personality. Like Gilbert and like new manager Tony Vitello, Bader is known for playing with an edge and having a bit of a swagger–the kind of guy who sometimes rubs people the wrong way, which (perhaps surprisingly) Posey sees as a plus–he said as much when Vitello was hired. From yesterday’s call:
βI think weβve been pretty clear that we like that type of personality, the one thatβs going to go out and play with a bit of a chip on their shoulder,β Posey said. βI think he fits that bill.β
Bader himself expressed a lot of enthusiasm about coming to the Giants.Β From Susan Slusser’s article:
βGoing into the free agency for the third time this year, I really just wanted to find a home,β Bader said, βand I think a number of factors play into what a baseball player would identify as a home: Itβs winning culture, a really, really strong city, a culture in a city that is centered around baseball, good food, good energy. I ultimately picked San Francisco because the opportunity was just fantastic to go out there and play my game.β
For a guy who’s just 31, Bader has knocked around a bit. The Giants will be his seventh team. This is the first time since his early years with the Cardinals that a team has committed to him for multiple years and promised him an everyday role. His solid 2025 season, plus the fit between his skills and the Giants’ needs, gave him an opportunity he hasn’t quite had yet.
Other News from Posey
Posey’s call with the reporters covered other topics beyond the addition of Bader and what that also meant for Lee:
- Are they done making additions to the roster? If you read his quotes, Posey seemed to be saying that they’re still working on a possible upgrade at 2B but downplayed the idea that they might sign another starting pitcher.
- Who’s the closer?Β Ryan WalkerΒ told Susan Slusser of the Chronicle last week that he wants to reclaim the closer role he lost and regained (by default) during a very uneven 2025 season. Posey confirmed that they are “hoping that Ryan Walker can get back to his 2024 form” but added that “weβll see who steps up.”
- Is the coaching staff ever going to be announced? As Slusser put, it, “Posey said that the coaching staff is still ‘an ongoing conversation,’ which is highly unusual with spring camp opening Feb. 10. Vitello said two weeks ago there is a chance another name might be added to the staff.”
This article from MLB Trade Rumors summarizes a lot of these developments pretty well.
Buster Posey said Giants are happy with the rotation they have after adding Mahle/Houser. Posey: “You’re never going to close doors, but we feel good with the group that we have.” Also said they “still have some balls in the air” in terms of possible moves before spring training.
β Alex Pavlovic (@PavlovicNBCS) January 30, 2026
And here’s a comment last night from ESPN’s Jeff Passan, who was the one who said the Giants were “aggressively pursuing” a 2B upgrade.
He thinks itβs funny π pic.twitter.com/mq8S06q7H3
β Giant Hot Takes (@GiantHotTakes) January 31, 2026
Rankings can be “Rank”
It’s the time of year where various entities come out with their rankings–the Top Ten Right Now series at MLB Network, the Top 100 prospects and players, farm system rankings, and prospect rankings. Some of these came out pretty well for the Giants and others were a bit disappointing. For example, on the Top Ten Right Now, Logan WebbΒ andΒ Willy Adames both “just missed” the Shredder’s list at their respective positions, though the studio analysts (Brian Kenny and Ron Darling) both had Webb on their lists. Darling, in fact, had Webb at #3, right after defending Cy Young winners Tarik Skubal and Paul Skenes.Β Bryce EldridgeΒ dropped down quite a few spots on some lists but also was named as the #1 power-hitting prospect by MLB Pipeline. Keith Law of the Athletic ranked the Giants’ farm system at #13. When you recall that MLB.com had the Giants ranked at #28 this time last year, it’s clear that things are looking up organizationally.
To summarize the various prospect lists, five current prospects made one or more top-100 lists (MLB, Baseball America, ESPN, Law):
- Eldridge (all of them)
- Josuar Gonzalez (all of them)
- Jhonny Level (BA, ESPN)
- Bo Davidson (BA)
- Gavin Kilen (Law)
In another ranking,Β Patrick BaileyΒ was named the best defensive player in all of MLB. The tweet reminds us that Bailey somehow didΒ not win the Platinum Glove for 2025 because it turns out it’s a fan vote popularity contest. Remember who did? I’ll give you a hint: He’s not on Mike Petriello’s top-ten list here, so take that for what it’s worth.
Reminder that Bailey was robbed of the Platinum Glove https://t.co/yaRfBVQA7a
β SleeperSFGiants (@SleeperSFGiants) January 31, 2026
This Week
Today at noon is the third stop of the FanFest Tour, at Sutter Health Park in West Sacramento, home of the River Cats and the Athletics(!). The Mr and I are skipping it this year (last year was a rainy, sloppy, crowded mess), but we’ll look forward to hearing Crawnik’s report, as he’s attending it.Β So far the tour stops have been very well attended, including a record-setting 12K+ in San Ramon last weekend. This last point is interesting because it’s the first time since they started the tour model three years ago that they’ve had an East Bay site. This bodes well for the Giants’ total takeover of the Bay Area once the A’s are out of Northern California. (Note to Greg J.: That means you can SPEND MONEY.)
It’s exciting that the calendar flips to February tomorrow. Camp opens on Feb. 10 this year, earlier than usual because some players will be leaving for the WBC. At this point, we know that Webb will pitch for Team USA, Lee will play for Team Korea,Β Tristan BeckΒ will play for Team Great Britain (turns out his mom is British), and we haven’t heard yet about Adames or Rafael DeversΒ (for Team Dominican Republic) or Ramos (for Team Puerto Rico, though it was just announced that Team PR may withdraw from the WBC). We also know that Team USA will play against the Giants on March 3 at Scottsdale Stadium. That’s kind of cool. We arrive in Scottsdale for our annual spring training trip on March 5, so we’ll just miss it.
Perhaps there will be more news about the “balls in the air” that Posey mentioned in the call with reporters yesterday. Or we’ll see a list of non-roster invitees to spring training. Maybe we’ll even find out who all is on the coaching staff! It could be an eventful week. Lefty out.