by DrLefty

[Hat-tip to Ryan for the idea for the title and cover image.]

Thanks to all for the good wishes about my sesame challenge yesterday. Before I was allergic (the allergy first surfaced when I was in my mid-30s), sesame bagels were my favorite, Chinese food was my favorite, and Whopper Juniors from Burger King (sesame buns) were my favorite. One of my unscientific theories has been that I ate SO MUCH sesame as a young adult that I brought this allergy on myself somehow. I had sesame oil in my kitchen and had just cooked with it the week before my very first allergic episode.

Anyway, there’s a sesame bagel for old times’ sake.


Bagels in the Outfield

It’s February 2, which is Groundhog Day, which reminds me of the great Bill Murray movie of the same name, in which he has to keep living the same day over and over “until he gets it right.”


It definitely feels like we’ve been talking about the Giants’ outfield deficiencies forever, or at least since around 2013 or so. The World Series champion 2012 Giants had a pretty good outfield. Early in the season, it was Blanco, Pagan, and Melky Cabrera. Later (starting in August), there was Hunter Pence. That group of outfielders (which also included Nate Schierholtz until he was traded for Pence) put up doubles, triples, stolen bases, good defense, and lots of hits.

Starting in 2013, though, things began to go sour. Pence and Pagan manned RF and CF, but the Opening Day left field platoon was Andres Torres 2.0 (and you know what they say about sequels) and Blanco. Pagan ended up missing more than half of the season with a hamstring injury, and Blanco ended up in CF. The Giants had quite a LF parade after that, including #ForeverGiants Jeff Francoeur, Kensuke Tanaka, and Brett Pill. I could go on, but you get the idea. Pretty much every year since, we’ve said something along the lines of “They HAVE to do something about the outfield, don’t they? DON’T THEY?!”

Groundhog Day.

As I mentioned in last week’s post, this time last year we were bemoaning the decrepitude of the Giants’ outfield, which on the Opening Day roster featured five (5) guys over 30 (Pence, McCutchen, Austin Jackson, Blanco, and Gorkys), while younger guys who had good springs (Mac and Duggar) were sent to AAA. This year we have the exact opposite situation. All five of those veteran outfielders are gone, and we will have a completely new Opening Day outfield on March 28 in AT & T–oops, Oracle–South. (Can it be “Oracle South” before there’s ever been a game played at Oracle North? Asking for a friend.)

So here’s what we have as of Feb. 2, including yesterday’s addition of #ForeverGiant John Andreoli (more on him in a minute). This chart includes all of the outfielders on the current 40-man roster, infielders who also play outfield (Belt, Hanson, Jones), and the non-roster invitees (Ramos, Garcia and Gerber–Gerber still has a spring training invite).


This is…wow. This is a lot of inexperience. Twelve guys will be in camp who could potentially play the outfield. The leader in ABs is Slater at 316 and in innings is Mac Williamson at 678. Belt is a first baseman and an occasional reluctant left fielder. Hanson and Jones are primarily infielders, and even Slater has moved between the infield and outfield his whole pro career. Now, in the Zaidi Regime, such versatility is considered a good thing, but it can also mean “mediocre everywhere” (Hanson, for example, hasn’t impressed me defensively at any position he’s played. Hanson in the outfield gave me the shudders.) The only true dedicated outfielders on the list are Andreoli, Duggar, Williamson, Shaw (sort of) and non-roster invitees (Garcia, Gerber, and Ramos). However you slice and dice this, it’s pretty slim pickings.

You have to believe that Zaidi is still going to sign and/or trade for a more experienced outfielder(s). There was this tweet about the Giants from Jon Heyman last night:

Now, one should always take tweets from Jon Heyman with a whole shaker of salt, but this one has the ring of truth. I assume he meant “lowball bids,” not “buds,” but it makes sense that Zaidi, a careful, analytical guy, would try to wait out the market and get some good deals. I’ll guess that before camp opens, there will be at least one new free agent outfielder with actual major league experience. (Adam Jones? CarGo or CarGo? We shall see.)

Heyman also listed the Giants, in a different tweet, as among the teams still looking for starters, which also seems plausible.


Hello Andreoli, Goodbye Derek Law

I was surprised last week when the Giants DFA’d Mike Gerber after signing Drew Pomeranz. With nine cajillion pitchers and tons of lefties on the 40-man roster, it didn’t make much sense to me that you’d slice from your already-thin outfield corps. So now they’ve gone the other way, picking up an outfielder off waivers from the Rangers (John Andreoli) and DFA’ing right-handed reliever Derek Law.

Here’s a photo of Andreoli. Anyone get a Ryder Jones lookalike vibe from this? I went looking for a picture of Andreoli and found one of him wearing a Mariners cap (he briefly played for Seattle last season). As I was clicking on the photo, it magically changed into a Giants cap, even though they just got him yesterday. The miracles of technology!

New Giants outfielder John Andreoli

Zaidi clearly has a “type” in mind with all of these minor league outfielder pickups, and Andreoli fits: high OBP in the minors, speedy (stole some bags), plays all three outfield spots, and not much pop. (Garcia had 25 AAA homers last year, but none of the others has demonstrated much power.)

As for Derek Law, it’s a sad story. A 2011 Giants’ draftee (ninth round), Law impressed early on in the minors, was invited to spring training in 2014, and almost made the team out of camp. Then he blew out his elbow and had to have Tommy John surgery in mid-2014. Law finally made his major league debut in early 2016 and had a fine rookie season, making 61 appearances and putting up an ERA of 2.13, and ERA+ of 190, and a WHIP of .0964, plus a K/BB ratio of 50/9 in 55 innings pitched. He appeared in three of the four NLDS games against the Cubs, where he pitched well. I will always remember Law’s cheerleading during Game 3 of that series, the only game the Giants won. This is from one of the game stories:

After leaving the game, Law spent the rest of the night waving an orange rally towel — provided by a fan — on the top steps of the dugout.

“Even when he was out of the game, he was doing a pretty good job of cheerleading, too,” Bochy said.

“But what a great job he did. And, really, it’s been a good year for him. His rookie season, [he] really stepped up, and he was one of our guys in the 7th, 8th inning and was doing a real nice job.”

But then Game 4 happened. The Giants went into the top of the ninth leading 5-2, just needing three more outs to take the series back to Chicago for a decisive Game 5 with Johnny Cueto ready to go and Bumgarner available in the bullpen. In a decision that is still questioned by some Giants fans, Bochy pulled Matt Moore, who’d been dominant for eight innings, and handed the ball to Law, who gave up a bleeder single that just got by Brandon Crawford. Out came Bochy with a quick hook, and the rest of that inning will go down in Giants infamy. Did that final moment shake Law’s confidence, something to stew over the whole winter?

Law came into the 2017 season expected to be the set-up man for new closer Mark Melancon. Opening Day in Arizona was a dark foreshadowing of one of the worst seasons in Giants’ franchise history, with first Law and then Melancon blowing saves after Bumgarner’s two homers had started the Giants off with a bang. It was also the beginning of the end for Law’s Giants career. He had a brief bright spot in May, when he stepped in for an injured Melancon and converted four of four save opportunities, but by June he was pitching so poorly that he’d been demoted to AAA, and he pretty much was an afterthought from then on, appearing in only seven games for the Giants in 2018 while fellow righty prospects Reyes Moronta and Ray Black passed him up. And now he’s been DFA’d. Will he clear waivers and return to the Giants? I’m guessing someone out there might remember his rookie season and think they can fix him. He’s still just going into his age-28 season. So goodbye–maybe–and good luck to DLaw. We’ll always have 2016.

#ForeverGiant Derek Law

Other News

Here’s a nice article by Dalton Johnson of the San Jose Mercury News on top Giants pitching prospect Logan Webb. He’s one to keep an eye on this spring and season. I’m assuming he’ll start the year at Richmond.

Two other off-the-field “signings” were Grant Brisbee, leaving SBN to join The Athletic and co-cover the Giants with Andrew Baggarly, and Dave Flemming signing a four-year extension with the Giants, even upping his contract from 130 games per season to 140. I think both of these developments are great news for Giants fans. Flemming is, in my opinion, a superb play-by-play man, and his partnership with Jon Miller has become epic over the years. Brisbee is funny and silly, but don’t let that fool you. He’s also insightful and he can really write. With him, Baggarly, Dan Brown, and Melissa Lockard covering the Giants’ minor leaguers, Giants fans subscribing to The Athletic are really spoiled now.

(If you haven’t yet made the plunge, you can get a 40% discount for the next week or so by following this link:


The Fan Fest is one week from today. Pitchers and catchers report in Scottsdale in ten days. Baseball is almost back, and even if everything is coming up bagels in the outfield right now, it’s still baseball. Have a sesame bagel for me today–Lefty out.